You don’t need an algorithm to tell you what music moved you most this past year. I’m sure, if you took the time to think about it, you could fire off the same ten songs/artists/albums it can.
You don’t need an algorithm to tell you your top photos or moments. I’m sure you can go through your roll and chose a better reflection of what was really special about this year.
Any list you do yourself would be better than any algorithm as it would likely not be based on numbers or stats or engagement. Instead, your list would be based what you care enough to remember. How it made you feel. The algorithm can’t know what matters. The algorithm can’t give you the why.
I know my top artist this year on numbers alone would be Taylor Swift. Am I a huge Taylor fan? No. I think she’s talented. I genuinely like her work. The reason is that she ends up being a lingua franca for our family. The one thing we can put on in the car together and all enjoy and sing along to. She’s the choice when we can’t think of or agree on anything else.
I’m sure the Original Broadway cast recordings of Hamilton (yes, still) and Hadestown (The original, original. Not the new original. Not the concept album which I love but don’t listen to enough) and Spring Awakening. Why? Same reasons. It’s what to listen to when I can’t decide. It is my sensible default.
I’m sure the algorithm wouldn’t tell me how much I enjoyed the new albums by Tears For Fears or The The, because I own them and did not stream them. It would not tell me about the live concert recording of a Mumford and Sons show at First Avenue I attended years ago that I mastered off a radio station’s simulcast that I often listen to on a CD rip in my car. Or my CD mix of 80’s new wave. The algorithm can’t see me there.
The algorithm doesn’t really know me that well. It doesn’t know what I do where it can’t see. It doesn’t know why I choose to do it.
Make your own end of year lists. Choose your own important memories. Pick the songs you loved and share it with the world. You don’t need an algorithm. You just need to care.